Background

Closure with Abusers

Uploaded 10/12/2010, approx. 3 minute read

I am Sam Vaknin, and I am the author of Malignant Self-Love, Narcissism Revisited.

For her traumatic wounds to heal, the victim of abuse requires closure.

One final interaction with her tormentor, in which he, hopefully, will acknowledge his misbehavior and even tender an apology.

Fair chance. Few abusers, especially if they are narcissistic, are amenable to such weak-link pleasantries.

More often, the abuse are left to wallow in a poisonous tool of misery, self-pity, and self-reclusion.

Depending on the severity, duration, and nature of the abuse, there are three forms of effective closure.

There is conceptual closure. This is the most common variant. It involves a frank discussion of the abusive relationship. The parties meet to analyze what went wrong, to allocate blame and guilt, to derive lessons, and to part ways cathartically cleansed.

In such an exchange, a compassionate offender, quite the oxymoron, admittedly, offers his prey the chance to rid herself of accumulating resentment. He also disabuses her of the notion that she, in any way, was guilty or responsible for her maltreatment, that it was all her fault, that she deserved to be punished, and that she could have saved a relationship.

I call it malignant optimism. With this burden gone, the victim is ready to resume her life, to seek companionship or love elsewhere.

Then there is retributive closure. When the abuse had been gratuitous, sadistic, repeated, and protracted, conceptual closure is not enough. Retribution is called for, an element of vengeance, of restorative justice, and a restored balance.

Recuperation hinges on punishing the delinquent and merciless party. The penal intervention of the law is often therapeutic to the abused.

Some victims delude themselves into believing that their abuser is experiencing guilt and conscience, which rarely is the case. They revel in his ostensible, self-inflicted torment. His sleepless nights become their sweet revenge, but it's all self-delusion.

Abuses are not like that.

Regrettably, the victim's understandable emotions often lead to abusive and illegal acts on the victim's part. Many of the tormented stalk their erstwhile abusers and take the law into their own hands.

Abuse tends to breed abuse all around, in both prey and predator.

Finally, there is dissociative closure.

Absent the other two forms of closure, the conceptual and the retributive, victims of egregious and prolonged misfeedment tend to repress their painful memories.

In extremists, they dissociate.

The dissociative identity disorder, known formally as multiple personality disorder, is thought to be such a reaction to abuse.

The harrowing experiences are sliced off, they are tucked away, and they are attributed to another person or personality.

Sometimes the victim assimilates his or her tormentor, and even openly and consciously identifies with him and emulates him. This is the narcissistic defense.

In his own anguished mind, the victim becomes omnipotent and therefore invulnerable. He or she develops a false self. The true self is thus shielded from further harm and injury by the false self.

False self is omnipotent, omniscient, nothing can hurt or pain the false self.

According to psychodynamic theories of psychopathology, repressed content rendered unconscious is the cause of all manner of mental health disorders and even psychosomatic disorders.

The victim pays a hefty price for avoiding and evading his or her predicament.

We will discuss coping with various forms of stoking in one of our future videos. Stay tuned.

If you enjoyed this article, you might like the following:

Closure is Bad for You

Closure, a popular concept in psychology, originally came from Gestalt therapy and referred to image processing. However, it has been inappropriately expanded to include trauma, relationships, and more. Many experts and psychologists now consider closure a myth and even counterproductive. Instead of seeking closure, one should focus on embracing and integrating pain and negative experiences as part of personal growth and development.


Genius or Gifted? IQ and Beyond (News Intervention Interview)

In this transcript, Professor Sam Vaknin discusses IQ, intelligence, genius, and giftedness in an interview with News Intervention. He clarifies that any result above 160 is not normatively validated and that intelligence is anything that endows an individual with a comparative advantage at performing a complex task. He also explains that giftedness resembles autism and that it is the ability to accomplish tasks inordinately well or fast by focusing on them to the exclusion of all else. Additionally, he notes that many so-called geniuses with high IQ are dysfunctional and deficient when it comes to life, intimacy, relationships, and social skills.


Narcissism and Syphilis

Cephalis, a sexually transmitted disease, can go dormant for years before affecting the brain in a condition known as general paresis. Brain tissue is gradually destroyed by the tiny organisms that cause Cephalis, causing pneumonia, dementia, megalomania, delusions of grandeur, and paranoia. Cephalitic patients in the tertiary, brain-consuming stage are often described as brutal, suspicious, delusional, moody, irritable, raging, lacking empathy, grandiose, and demanding, which can be misdiagnosed as bipolar disorder combined with narcissistic and paranoid personality disorders. It is easy to confuse tertiary syphilis with personality disorders, especially the narcissistic and paranoid ones.


How Narcissist, Borderline Overperceives YOU (and Reality)

Over perception is a cognitive bias where individuals exaggerate or misinterpret others' emotions, intentions, and behaviors, leading to distorted perceptions of reality. This phenomenon manifests differently in various mental health disorders, such as sexual over perception in men and intimacy over perception in individuals with histrionic personality disorder. Additionally, narcissists exhibit over perception of slights and narcissistic supply, which reinforces their grandiosity, while individuals with borderline personality disorder may over perceive abandonment. Cognitive biases, while often seen as negative, can serve adaptive functions in decision-making and emotional regulation, highlighting the complex interplay between perception, cognition, and mental health.


Right to Suicide: Teen, Adult, State, Prevention (2nd Webinar on Mental Health and Suicidal Risk)

Teen suicide is increasingly linked to social media, which is designed to be addictive and creates significant pressure and anxiety among users, particularly teens. The rise in diagnosed anxiety and depression among adolescents correlates with increased screen time, leading to feelings of isolation and insecurity. Suicide is portrayed as a societal issue rather than merely a mental health one, with individuals often signaling their distress before attempting to take their own lives. Addressing the root causes of loneliness and disconnection in society, rather than solely focusing on the act of suicide itself, is essential for prevention.


5 Reasons To Grieve, Mourn: Varieties Of Grief And Mourning

Healthy grief typically lasts about a year and leads to the integration of memories, while prolonged grief disorder persists beyond that and can involve obsessive thoughts. There are five primary reasons for grief: unrealized potential, the gap between fantasy and reality, catastrophizing perceived threats, actual irretrievable loss, and grief that becomes an identity due to early trauma. Each type of grief corresponds to specific causes that can either be processed healthily or become entrenched, leading to depression and anxiety for both the individual and those around them. Ultimately, grief is a complex human experience that encompasses not only real losses but also the mourning of unrealized dreams and identities.


Mental Illness: Gift? Asset?

Mental illness can be perceived as an asset in a hostile and chaotic world, as it often deters aggression from others who fear unpredictable behavior. It is also viewed as a gateway to unique insights and knowledge that conforming individuals may lack, positioning the mentally ill as possessors of hidden truths. Additionally, the impulsive and rebellious nature of mental illness allows individuals to challenge societal norms, making them figures of admiration and envy. Consequently, mental illness is increasingly seen as aspirational in contemporary society, reflecting a complex relationship between mental health and social dynamics.


COVID-19 Clones Borderlines, Psychopaths: Real Zombie Apocalypse (Depression and Psychiatry Webinar)

COVID-19 appears to have significant and potentially irreversible effects on the central nervous system, leading to neurological damage that resembles traits of cluster B personality disorders, particularly borderline and antisocial personality disorders. Neuroimaging studies indicate that a substantial number of COVID-19 patients, including asymptomatic individuals, exhibit brain changes that may predispose them to emotional dysregulation and antisocial behaviors. The virus's ability to infiltrate the brain and disrupt critical areas responsible for emotional and cognitive functions raises concerns about a looming mental health crisis, as millions may develop traits indistinguishable from psychopathy or borderline personality disorder. The long-term implications of these changes remain uncertain, but historical precedents suggest that such neurological damage could be permanent, posing a significant threat to societal stability.


Giftedness or Self? (with Katja Ujčič)

Gifted individuals often experience a disconnect between their cognitive abilities and their sense of self, leading to feelings of alienation and dissonance. The education system currently favors average individuals, neglecting the unique needs of gifted people, which could be addressed by creating tailored educational environments. There is a misconception that giftedness correlates with moral goodness, but gifted individuals can exhibit a wide range of moral behaviors, and their contributions to society can be both positive and negative. Ultimately, the societal stigmatization of giftedness and the elevation of mediocrity pose significant challenges for gifted individuals, making it crucial to foster communities where they can thrive and feel accepted.


Insanity of Insanity Defense (2nd International Conference and Expo on Clinical Psychology)

The culpability of individuals with mental illness in legal contexts remains a complex and debated issue, with historical roots and varying interpretations across cultures. The distinction between psychiatric and legal definitions of insanity complicates the application of the insanity defense, as mental health professionals often view mental illness through a lens of impaired reality perception, while legal systems focus on intent and capacity to understand right from wrong. The variability in diagnosing mental disorders, influenced by cultural norms and societal values, raises questions about the objectivity and universality of such classifications, suggesting that many behaviors deemed pathological may actually reflect social constructs rather than immutable medical conditions. Ultimately, the intersection of mental health and legal accountability highlights the need for a nuanced understanding of both fields, acknowledging the limitations of current psychiatric frameworks and the potential for societal biases in defining and treating mental illness.

Transcripts Copyright © Sam Vaknin 2010-2024, under license to William DeGraaf
Website Copyright © William DeGraaf 2022-2024
Get it on Google Play
Privacy policy