Background

Closure with Abusers

Uploaded 10/12/2010, approx. 3 minute read

I am Sam Vaknin, and I am the author of Malignant Self-Love, Narcissism Revisited.

For her traumatic wounds to heal, the victim of abuse requires closure.

One final interaction with her tormentor, in which he, hopefully, will acknowledge his misbehavior and even tender an apology.

Fair chance. Few abusers, especially if they are narcissistic, are amenable to such weak-link pleasantries.

More often, the abuse are left to wallow in a poisonous tool of misery, self-pity, and self-reclusion.

Depending on the severity, duration, and nature of the abuse, there are three forms of effective closure.

There is conceptual closure. This is the most common variant. It involves a frank discussion of the abusive relationship. The parties meet to analyze what went wrong, to allocate blame and guilt, to derive lessons, and to part ways cathartically cleansed.

In such an exchange, a compassionate offender, quite the oxymoron, admittedly, offers his prey the chance to rid herself of accumulating resentment. He also disabuses her of the notion that she, in any way, was guilty or responsible for her maltreatment, that it was all her fault, that she deserved to be punished, and that she could have saved a relationship.

I call it malignant optimism. With this burden gone, the victim is ready to resume her life, to seek companionship or love elsewhere.

Then there is retributive closure. When the abuse had been gratuitous, sadistic, repeated, and protracted, conceptual closure is not enough. Retribution is called for, an element of vengeance, of restorative justice, and a restored balance.

Recuperation hinges on punishing the delinquent and merciless party. The penal intervention of the law is often therapeutic to the abused.

Some victims delude themselves into believing that their abuser is experiencing guilt and conscience, which rarely is the case. They revel in his ostensible, self-inflicted torment. His sleepless nights become their sweet revenge, but it's all self-delusion.

Abuses are not like that.

Regrettably, the victim's understandable emotions often lead to abusive and illegal acts on the victim's part. Many of the tormented stalk their erstwhile abusers and take the law into their own hands.

Abuse tends to breed abuse all around, in both prey and predator.

Finally, there is dissociative closure.

Absent the other two forms of closure, the conceptual and the retributive, victims of egregious and prolonged misfeedment tend to repress their painful memories.

In extremists, they dissociate.

The dissociative identity disorder, known formally as multiple personality disorder, is thought to be such a reaction to abuse.

The harrowing experiences are sliced off, they are tucked away, and they are attributed to another person or personality.

Sometimes the victim assimilates his or her tormentor, and even openly and consciously identifies with him and emulates him. This is the narcissistic defense.

In his own anguished mind, the victim becomes omnipotent and therefore invulnerable. He or she develops a false self. The true self is thus shielded from further harm and injury by the false self.

False self is omnipotent, omniscient, nothing can hurt or pain the false self.

According to psychodynamic theories of psychopathology, repressed content rendered unconscious is the cause of all manner of mental health disorders and even psychosomatic disorders.

The victim pays a hefty price for avoiding and evading his or her predicament.

We will discuss coping with various forms of stoking in one of our future videos. Stay tuned.

If you enjoyed this article, you might like the following:

Closure is Bad for You

Closure, a popular concept in psychology, originally came from Gestalt therapy and referred to image processing. However, it has been inappropriately expanded to include trauma, relationships, and more. Many experts and psychologists now consider closure a myth and even counterproductive. Instead of seeking closure, one should focus on embracing and integrating pain and negative experiences as part of personal growth and development.


Wounded Inner Child Undermines Adult

The inner child concept refers to the emotional and mental age discrepancy that exists within individuals, often resulting from unmet childhood needs and experiences of trauma or dysfunction. This inner child can manifest as a wounded part of the self that seeks validation and fulfillment from others, leading to maladaptive behaviors and emotional responses in adulthood. Therapeutic approaches, such as reparenting and corrective emotional experiences, aim to address these wounds by fostering understanding, compassion, and healthy interactions, ultimately facilitating growth and integration of the self. The goal is to help individuals navigate their inner child's needs while developing effective adult coping mechanisms, thereby reducing shame and promoting emotional healing.


Magical Thinking in Personality Disorders and Conspiracy Theorists

Magical thinking is a developmental stage in childhood that can become pathological in adulthood, leading to distorted perceptions of reality where individuals believe their thoughts can directly influence the external world. This form of thinking is often exploited by unscrupulous individuals, such as cult leaders and self-help gurus, who encourage regressive beliefs and behaviors for personal gain. It manifests in various mental health disorders, including narcissism and borderline personality disorder, where individuals may confuse internal thoughts with external realities, leading to impaired reality testing and grandiosity. Ultimately, the prevalence of magical thinking in society reflects a broader refusal to mature, posing risks to both individual well-being and societal stability.


Therapist Your Father, Wife Your Mother: Transference as Flashback Light

Transference involves displacing emotions and ideas from significant figures in one's past onto new relationships, such as a therapist or partner, leading to a confusion of identities. This phenomenon can perpetuate dysfunctional relational patterns and enhance the significance of new individuals beyond their actual importance, often resulting in dependency or addiction. Individuals with relational dysfunctions, such as those with certain attachment styles, are more prone to exaggerated transference, which can lead to coercive behaviors aimed at forcing new figures to conform to familiar dynamics. Ultimately, transference acts as a resistance that reenacts early experiences with the hope of achieving a resolution that rarely occurs.


The Intimate Partner as a Persecutory Object: Love is a Battlefield

The persecutory object is a tormenting, devaluing, and sadistic inner voice that informs patients with certain personality disorders that they are bad, worthless, weak, immoral, and generally a disappointment. Patients project this voice onto their intimate partners, who become the outer embodiment of the internal construct. This defense mechanism is known as projective identification. The patient tries to force the partner to behave in ways that support their view of them as a persecutory object. The patient then rebels against their externalized persecutory object, punishing their partner in myriad ways, leading to a sick dynamic that is unfortunately very common.


When Narcissist Reminds You of Someone: Narcissistic Transferences (Idealizing, Mirror, Twinship)

Transference is a psychological phenomenon where individuals project feelings and expectations from significant past relationships onto new people, often leading to distorted perceptions and interactions. This process can manifest in various forms, including idealizing, mirror, and twin-ship transferences, each affecting how one relates to others based on unresolved childhood dynamics. Narcissistic transference specifically involves the expectation that others fulfill unmet emotional needs from earlier relationships, which can create dysfunctional patterns in interactions. Ultimately, while transference can provide insight into one's psychological state, it often constrains personal growth and the ability to engage with others authentically.


Can We Survive Without Fantasies, Delusions? (Verbal Conditioning)

Delusions and fantasies can entrap individuals, rendering them vulnerable to exploitation and creating significant challenges in interpersonal relationships. Confronting someone entrenched in delusion requires careful consideration, as these beliefs often serve as coping mechanisms rooted in early childhood experiences and can provide meaning and motivation in their lives. Attempting to dismantle these delusions without offering a viable alternative can lead to aggression or depression, making it crucial to approach the situation with empathy and understanding. Ultimately, the challenge lies in addressing the underlying issues while fostering a healthier reality that individuals can engage with meaningfully.


Your Introjects (Inner Voices) are NOT YOU!

The internal objects, introjects, and voices that populate your inner world are not a part of your core identity, but rather a kind of attribution error. These voices are triggered by circumstances and events in your life, but they are not your identity. Silencing the introjects does have an effect on your behavior and choices, but it doesn't have an effect on who you are. Therapies such as cognitive behavior therapy, schema therapy, and Gestalt therapy can help silence these introjects and remove them, leaving your authentic self.


So, Can You Change Your Attachment Style?

Attachment styles are stable but attachment behaviors can be modified. The internal relationship model is formed in childhood and influences how people interact and build relationships. Life crises and having a good partner can mitigate insecure attachment styles, but personal growth and development come from being vulnerable and open to loss. Internal working models are dynamic and can change with self-awareness and experience.


Change Your Inner Dialog, Narrative Plot

The inner dialogue consists of various voices, including those of parents, peers, and societal expectations, which create a complex ego system that influences identity and self-perception. This dialogue often reflects societal pressures to conform and achieve, leading to feelings of inadequacy and unhappiness. To foster healing, one must identify the sources of these voices, discern which are authentic, and construct a narrative that is coherent, inclusive, and aligned with personal values rather than societal demands. Ultimately, achieving a state of happiness involves embracing one's existence and creating a meaningful narrative that promotes self-acceptance and integration, free from the distortions imposed by external expectations.

Transcripts Copyright © Sam Vaknin 2010-2024, under license to William DeGraaf
Website Copyright © William DeGraaf 2022-2024
Get it on Google Play
Privacy policy