Background

Labile: Borderline Personality Disorder and Narcissism

Uploaded 10/22/2010, approx. 3 minute read

I am Sam Vaknin, and I am the author of Malignant Self-Love, Narcissism Revisited.

The fact that borderline personality disorder is often found among women makes it a controversial mental health diagnosis.

Some scholars say that it is a culture-bound pseudo-syndrome invented by men to serve a patriarchal and misogynistic society.

Other scholars point to the fact that the lives of patients diagnosed with the disorder are chaotic and that the relationships they form are stormy, short-lived and unstable.

Moreover, not unlike compensatory narcissists, people with borderline personality disorder often display labile, wildly fluctuating sense of self-worth, self-image and affect. Their expressed emotions are all over the map.

Like both narcissists and psychopaths, borderlines are impulsive, they are reckless. Like histrionics, their sexual conduct is promiscuous, driven and unsafe.

Many borderlines binge eat, gamble, drive and shop carelessly, and they are substance abusers.

Lack of impulse control is joined with self-destructive and self-defeating behaviors such as suicidal ideation, suicide attempts, gestures of rage and self-mutilation or self-injury.

The main dynamic in borderline personality disorder is abandonment anxiety. Like codependents, borderlines attempt to preempt or prevent abandonment both real and imagined by their nearest and dearest.

They cling frantically and counter-productively to their partners, mates, spouses, friends, children or even in extreme cases, neighbors.

This fierce attachment is coupled with idealization and then swiftly and mercilessly devaluation of the borderline's target.

Exactly like the narcissist, the borderline patient elicits constant narcissistic supply.

The borderline craves, needs and seeks attention affirmation, adulation and approval. She needs all these in order to regulate her gyrating sense of self-worth and her chaotic self-image, in order to shore up serious, marked, persistent and ubiquitous deficits in self-esteem, in order to get her ego functions going and in order to counter the knowing emptiness at her core.

Borderline personality disorder is often co-diagnosed. It is comorbid with mood and affect disorders.

But all borderlines suffer from mood reactivity. Borderlines shift dizzingly between dysphoria, sadness or depression and euphoria, manic self-confidence and paralyzing anxiety, irritability and indifference.

This pendulum is reminiscent of the mood swings of bipolar disorder patients.

But borderlines are much angrier and more violent than bipolar. They usually get into physical fights, throw temper tantrums and have frightening rage attacks.

When stressed, many borderlines become psychotic though only briefly psychotic micro-episodes. They develop transient paranoid persecretary ideation and they have ideas of reference. They harbor the erroneous conviction that they are the focus of derision and malicious gossip.

Dissociative symptoms are not uncommon in borderlines. They lose stretches of time or objects and they forget events or facts with emotional content.

Hence the term borderline, first suggested by Otto Kernberg.

The borderline personality disorder is on the thin border line separating neurosis from psychosis.

If you enjoyed this article, you might like the following:

Borderline Woman as Dissociative Secondary Psychopath

Borderline Personality Disorder and Psychopathy may not be as different as previously thought. Recent studies suggest that Borderline and Histrionic Personality Disorders may be manifestations of secondary type psychopathy in women. Survivors of Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (CPTSD) also exhibit psychopathic and narcissistic behaviors. Borderline Personality Disorder can be described as a subspecies of Dissociative Identity Disorder, with mood lability and emotional dysregulation being outward manifestations of changes in self-states.


Rejection and Abandonment in Cluster B Personality Disorders and Their Intimate

Borderline personality disorder (BPD) has historically been associated with women, largely due to male-centric definitions and societal norms from past decades. Individuals with BPD, along with other Cluster B personality disorders, often struggle with issues of rejection, interpreting both real and perceived rejections as catastrophic, leading to extreme emotional responses and behaviors. The reactions to rejection vary among different personality types, with narcissists exhibiting rage, primary psychopaths viewing it as an obstacle, and secondary psychopaths experiencing profound emotional pain that can lead to aggressive behaviors. Overall, these disorders reflect a complex interplay of arrested development and dysfunctional attachment styles, resulting in significant challenges in interpersonal relationships and emotional regulation.


The Three Voices: Histrionic, Psychopathic, Borderline

Borderline personality disorder frequently coexists with other personality disorders, particularly histrionic, narcissistic, and antisocial, forming the Cluster B category. Women are predominantly affected by these comorbidities, with their experiences often leading to conflicting inner voices that influence their behavior and self-perception. When faced with emotional distress, these women may seek validation and intimacy through sexual encounters, but this can trigger panic and negative thoughts about sex, leading to feelings of guilt and shame. The resulting inner conflict can cause dissociation and a sense of detachment from their actions, complicating their emotional and sexual experiences.


Shapeshifting Borderline, Morphing Narcissist Identity Disturbance

Individuals with borderline personality disorder experience significant identity disturbances, often switching between different self-states, which can resemble dissociative identity disorder. This condition is characterized by feelings of emptiness and a lack of a coherent self, leading to emotional dysregulation and difficulties in interpersonal relationships. The concept of identity disturbance has evolved over time, with historical ties to schizophrenia, and current research suggests a strong correlation between identity issues and the development of borderline pathology. Ultimately, the experience of living with borderline personality disorder can be profoundly challenging, both for the individual and their loved ones, as it creates a chaotic and unstable relational dynamic.


Pseudoidentities in Cluster B Personality Disorders: Spectacle and Simulacra

Borderline personality disorder can lead individuals to exhibit secondary psychopathic traits under extreme stress, differentiating them from primary psychopaths who lack empathy and emotions. The concept of pseudo-identities is central to understanding cluster B personality disorders, where individuals may shift between overt and covert states, often as a response to emotional dysregulation and identity disturbance. This identity disturbance results in a fragmented sense of self, leading to confusion and instability in their roles, values, and emotional responses. The transitions between these states are not only common but can occur rapidly, reflecting a lack of cohesive identity and a reliance on external validation and narratives to navigate their experiences.


From Borderline to Psychopath to Narcissist: Abuse of Language and Self States

Psychopathy, narcissism, and borderline personality disorders may represent different facets of a single underlying condition characterized by dissociation and fragmented self-states. These disorders often exhibit comorbidity, as individuals may shift between traits of narcissism, borderline, and psychopathy depending on stressors and emotional triggers. The communication patterns of these individuals, often marked by palindromic speech and manipulative language, serve to obscure their internal chaos and maintain their grandiosity or emotional needs. Ultimately, these personality disorders can be viewed as variations of malignant self-love, where the absence of a cohesive self leads to adaptive but dysfunctional behaviors in response to early trauma and unmet emotional needs. The interplay between these disorders suggests a continuum rather than distinct categories, with individuals transitioning fluidly between them based on their circumstances.


Borderline's Miracle Healing

Borderline personality disorder (BPD) is less prevalent than commonly believed, affecting about 1-2% of the general population, yet it accounts for a significant portion of mental health treatment cases due to crises. The prognosis for BPD is generally positive, with many individuals experiencing spontaneous remission or significant improvement through therapies like Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT), leading to a high percentage of patients no longer meeting diagnostic criteria over time. While symptoms related to impulsivity and behavior tend to remit more quickly, some underlying traits and dysfunctional behaviors may persist even after the disorder itself has resolved. Effective treatment should not only address the core symptoms of BPD but also focus on helping individuals develop functional skills for social and vocational success, particularly in younger populations.


GREAT NEWS New Treatments, BPD Redefined ( Borderline Personality Disorder Literature Review)

Recent research has revealed significant advancements in the understanding and treatment of borderline personality disorder (BPD), challenging previous misconceptions about its diagnosis and management. Notably, a study demonstrated that individuals with BPD do not need to engage in self-harm or suicidal behavior to qualify for the diagnosis, emphasizing the importance of emotional dysregulation as a key criterion. Additionally, new treatment modalities, such as combined individual and group schema therapy, have shown promise in effectively reducing BPD symptoms, while early interventions focusing on clinical case management rather than psychotherapy may be more beneficial for young patients. Overall, these findings suggest a shift towards a more nuanced and hopeful approach to diagnosing and treating BPD, highlighting the need for greater awareness and understanding among clinicians.


New Light on Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) in DSM-5-TR and ICD-11

Psychology is currently in turmoil with new diagnostic texts, definitions, and clinical insights. The DSM-5 text revision and the ICD-11 both offer new approaches to understanding borderline personality disorder (BPD). The distinction between complex trauma and BPD is blurry, and some scholars argue that various personality disorders, including narcissistic and borderline, should be considered post-traumatic conditions. The ICD-11 has moved towards a dimensional approach, focusing on aspects like identity, empathy, and antagonism, suggesting that all personality disorders may be part of a single underlying clinical entity.


Borderline Personality Disorder Patient Therapy Notes

Do is a 26-year-old female diagnosed with borderline personality disorder. She struggles with maintaining a stable sense of self-worth and self-esteem, and her confidence in holding onto men is low. She has had six serious relationships in the past year, all of which ended due to violent fights over trivial matters. Do admits to physically assaulting three of her ex-partners and has suicidal ideation, which sometimes manifests in minor acts of self-injury and self-mutilation. She also struggles with drug use, shopping addiction, and binge eating.

Transcripts Copyright © Sam Vaknin 2010-2024, under license to William DeGraaf
Website Copyright © William DeGraaf 2022-2024
Get it on Google Play
Privacy policy