Background

Søren Kierkegaard on Self, Love, and Self-love (Text in Description)

Uploaded 10/8/2020, approx. 5 minute read

I want to read to you something written by Soren Kierkegaard, the Danish religious philosopher.

Danish philosopher Kierkegaard is the founder of modern existentialism.

He wrote a lot about Christianity, morality, ethics, religion, and one of his books is called The Works of Love, a wonderful book.

In the book he says that Jesus said, you shall love your neighbor as yourself.

And then Kierkegaard asked himself, Jesus said you should love your neighbor as you love yourself.

Is Jesus commanding us to love ourselves?

If you don't love yourself, you can't love your neighbor according to Jesus.

So you must love yourself.

And indeed, in the Roman Catholic tradition, you can't love God truly if you don't love yourself.

In the Protestant tradition, self-love became narcissism in the Protestant tradition.

The Protestants are saying that if you self-love, you can't really love others.

You can't love your neighbors. You can't love your colleagues. You can't love your family. You can't love God.

Self-love is a barrier. It's a firewall.

It's a defense against loving others, against what we call object relations.

In Catholicism, and with Kierkegaard, it's not the case, he believes you must self-love. You must love yourself. It's a dictum by God and Jesus, and without this, you can't love anyone else.

Kierkegaard admits that you need to love yourself very subtly.

There is a type of self-love that is deeply unhealthy, destroys humanity, and there is proper self-love.

Proper self-love makes us whole, makes us complete persons.

So according to Kierkegaard, what Jesus said is not that you should first love yourself and then love your neighbor, but you should realize that love for your neighbor and love for yourself are the same thing.

There is no self apart from others.

Relationships constitute the self, or in Jung's language, relationships constellate the self.

Kierkegaard doesn't call it love, he calls it forgiveness.

He says only when you forgive your neighbor, you truly forgive yourself, but you must forgive.

Here is a quote from his book. When it is said you should love your neighbor as yourself, therein is contained what is presupposed, that every man loves himself.

Is it possible for anyone to misunderstand this? As if it were the intention of Christianity to proclaim self-love as a prescriptive right?

On the contrary, it is its purpose to wrest self-love away from us human beings.

This implies loving one's self, but if one must love his neighbor as himself, then the command, like a pick, wrenches open the lock of self-love and thereby rests it away from a man.

This as yourself does not waver in its aim and with the firmness of the eternal it critically penetrates.

It reaches the innermost hiding place where a man loves himself.

It does not leave self-love the slightest excuse or the tiniest escape hatch.

As Jacob limped after having struggled with God, so shall self-love be broken if it has struggled with this phrase, which nevertheless does not seek to teach a man not to love himself, but in fact rather seeks to teach him proper self-love. Therefore - as yourself.

Suppose the most cunning deceiver who is ever in order, if possible, to have the opportunity of using many words and becoming loquacious (for then the deceiver would quickly conquer), were tempting to question the royal law year in and year out, "how shall I love my neighbor?"

Then the terse command, unchanged, will continue to repeat the short phrase, "as yourself."

And if any deceiver has deceived himself throughout his whole life by all sorts of verbosity concerning this subject, the eternal will only hold him to the terse word of the law, as yourself.

No one, to be sure, will be able to escape this command.

If it's as yourself comes as close to the life of self-love as is possible, then one's neighbor is again a qualification as fatally close to self-love as possible.

Self-love itself perceives that it is an impossibility to shirk this.

The only escape is the one which the Pharisees in their time also tried in order to justify themselves: to let it be doubtful who one's neighbor is - in order to get him out of one's life.

Self-love, says Kierkegaard, is loving another.

The self is the totality of our interconnected mesh with other people. That's our self, he says.

If we love ourselves, by definition we love the self which is all our human contacts and by extension all of humanity.

He denies actually the possibility of an individual.

He says that to have a self is to immerse yourself in the totality of the human experience and with all other people, with all other human beings.

If you think that you can survive and live and love yourself without the aid and the support and the involvement and the penetration of other people, you are what he calls a deceiver.

Truer words have never been spoken, ask any narcissist.

If you enjoyed this article, you might like the following:

Four Pillars of Self-love

Self-love involves having a realistic and healthy view of oneself, contrasting with the grandiosity of narcissism or the self-deprecation of others. It requires three tests: a realistic self-assessment, the pursuit of happiness, and the pursuit of favorable outcomes. Four conditions must be met for healthy self-love: self-awareness, self-acceptance, self-trust, and self-efficacy, each building upon the previous one. Ultimately, self-love is essential for survival and well-being, guiding individuals toward happiness and effective decision-making.


Narcissism is Opposite of Self-love (EXCERPT with Brad Carr)

Self-love is often misunderstood as narcissism or selfishness, but it is fundamentally about self-acceptance and being your own best friend. It serves as a protective mechanism that helps maintain a sense of self and enables genuine love for others; without it, individuals become vulnerable to self-sabotage and unhealthy relationships. The ability to love oneself is crucial for forming a coherent identity and retaining meaningful memories, as love is deeply intertwined with emotional experiences. Ultimately, self-love is essential for personal well-being and the capacity to engage in authentic relationships with others.


Are YOU an Adult? What is Adulthood? (South East European University, SEEU)

Adulthood is a complex phenomenon that cannot be defined solely by chronological age, as many individuals exhibit childlike behaviors regardless of their age. Five components of adulthood are identified: chronological, biological, emotional, social, and intellectual maturity, with the latter three being crucial for true adulthood. The modern view emphasizes psychological traits and personal autonomy over traditional markers like marriage or employment, suggesting that adulthood is a state of mind influenced by social constructs and individual experiences. Additionally, the concept of emerging adulthood highlights the extended transition period into adulthood, reflecting societal changes and the importance of finding meaning in one's life.


Nature vs. Nurture? BOTH

The debate between nature and nurture is a false dichotomy, as genes and the external environment interact in a unitary system that shapes human development. Genes are responsive to external influences, and this interaction creates a continuous feedback loop that affects both internal and external environments. The artificial distinctions between internal and external, or natural and artificial, hinder our understanding of the complex mechanisms that shape human identity and behavior. Recognizing the interconnectedness of all elements is essential for effective psychological practice and understanding the human experience.


Healthy Egotism is Self-love, NOT Narcissism

Egotism is defined as self-centeredness that often harms others, and there is no such thing as healthy egotism from a social perspective. The primary focus should be on one's own survival and well-being, which must take precedence over societal expectations or the needs of others. While self-love is essential for mental health and functioning, it should not be confused with the pursuit of pleasure, which can lead to dependency and narcissism. Ultimately, individuals must prioritize their own needs and well-being, even if it means conflicting with societal norms or moral principles.


Imitating Others, Becoming Us: Social Cognitive (Learning) Theory (SE European University, SEEU)

Psychology involves understanding human behavior through a combination of nature and nurture, where both genetic predispositions and environmental influences shape individuals. The debate on whether individuals shape society or vice versa highlights the dynamic interaction between personal agency and societal norms. Bandura's social cognitive theory emphasizes the role of observational learning and modeling, where individuals learn behaviors by observing others, leading to imitation and adaptation based on perceived outcomes. This process is influenced by attention, retention, and motivation, demonstrating that personal growth and development occur through continuous interaction with role models throughout life.


Wunderkind Narcissist Refuses to Grow Up

Gifted children often struggle later in life, particularly when they develop narcissistic traits, leading to a high likelihood of failure in various aspects such as careers and relationships. This phenomenon stems from their upbringing, where they are idolized and led to believe in their inherent superiority, fostering a sense of entitlement and a refusal to engage in hard work or commitment. As a result, these individuals may become socially isolated, misanthropic, and even develop malignant narcissism, characterized by sadistic tendencies towards others. Ultimately, the combination of entitlement, indolence, and a lack of empathy leads to significant personal and social consequences for gifted children who become narcissists.


How to Manage Toxic Shame

Shame is a complex, self-directed emotion characterized by self-negating anger and a sense of helplessness in the face of overwhelming external circumstances or uncontrollable internal impulses. It is intertwined with prolonged grief over unrealized potential and the internalization of negative societal or parental judgments, leading to a harsh inner critic. While shame can serve as a moral compass, toxic shame arises when it becomes weaponized by internalized negative voices, resulting in self-destructive behavior. To manage toxic shame, one should learn to control anger, practice self-love, confront learned helplessness, avoid overwhelming situations, and maintain a disciplined approach to self-regulation.


Your Inner Voices Unlike Narcissist’s False Self (Literature Review)

Recent discussions about the prevalence of inner voices have misinterpreted studies, suggesting that 50 to 75% of people lack an internal monologue, when in fact this applies to a small fraction of those with aphantasia. Inner voices serve various functions, including providing guidance, moral reasoning, and even self-criticism, and can manifest in diverse ways, such as auditory or visual forms. The relationship between inner voices and the self is complex, with many individuals identifying closely with their internal dialogues, while narcissists may confuse their inner voice with their true self. Understanding and managing these inner voices is crucial for mental well-being, as they can influence emotions and behaviors significantly.


Shame, Guilt, Codependents, Narcissists, and Normal Folks

Children from dysfunctional families often develop intense feelings of shame, which can lead to co-dependency or narcissism, depending on their innate characteristics. Co-dependents are seen as resilient, while narcissists create a false self to evade shame, leading to anti-social behaviors when their grandiosity is challenged. Shame affects normal individuals by motivating them to apologize and conform, while for those with personality disorders, it triggers defensive and delusional reactions. The distinction between guilt and shame is crucial, as guilt is context-dependent and linked to moral agency, whereas shame arises from internalized feelings of inadequacy and alienation.

Transcripts Copyright © Sam Vaknin 2010-2024, under license to William DeGraaf
Website Copyright © William DeGraaf 2022-2024
Get it on Google Play
Privacy policy