Background

The Three Voices: Histrionic, Psychopathic, Borderline

Uploaded 9/23/2017, approx. 3 minute read

My name is Sam Vaknin, and I am the author of Malignant Self-Love, Narcissism Revisited.

Borderline personality disorder is often diagnosed together, is comorbid, with other personality disorders. Most commonly, histrionic, narcissistic, and antisocial, or psychopathic.

All these four personality disorders form together the Cluster B.

So, cluster B personality disorders often coexist in the same diagnosed patient.

The majority of persons diagnosed with these comorbidities of personality disorders are actually women. Women are predominantly the main segment of the histrionic personality disorder population and of the borderline personality disorder population.

Borderline personality disorder is a post-traumatic state. It is repeatedly triggered in later life by neglect, abandonment, withholding of sex and intimacy, verbal and psychological abuse, and by life's circumstances, dangers and chaos.

When borderline personality disorder is comorbid with histrionic personality disorder, such women react by seeking comfort, acceptance, validation, sex and intimacy from other men.

But the comorbidity creates conflicting inner voices in the woman. There are three voices to consider.

Histrionic voice, the antisocial voice or psychopathic voice, and the borderline voice.

The histrionic voice in such comorbid women says, men will make you feel better, men will help you restore your self-esteem.

The psychopathic or antisocial voice in such a woman says, don't feel guilty about cheating, don't feel guilty or bad about being a "whore". It is fun. You deserve sex. It is not your fault. No one gets hurt if you keep it a secret. Go for it.

The borderline voice says, your sexuality is bad, mad and dangerous. Don't take it too far or it will end calamitously.

When such a woman with comorbid histrionic and borderline personality disorder, when such a woman experiences a narcissistic crisis or a narcissistic injury, when such a woman is hurt, humiliated or frustrated, when her femininity is doubted or challenged, her histrionic side forces her to reach out to men in order to make her feel better and to ameliorate her frustration.

When such women fling with men, they use men to self-medicate. Men become a kind of anti-anxiety drug.

These women restore their self-esteem and self-confidence. They regulate their labile sense of self-worth by having sex or engaging in sexual acts with with men. These women contact men with the intention of having intimacy in sex with them.

When this happens, the antisocial or psychopathic voice of the woman legitimizes her histrionic behavior. It says, as I said, don't feel guilty about cheating. Don't feel guilty about being a whore. There's nothing wrong with it. It is fun. You deserve sex. It is not your fault. No one gets hurt if you keep it a secret and so on and so forth. Go for it.

But at that point, the borderline voice interjects.

The woman's borderline aspect feels stressed and panics by the sheer prospect of imminent sex.

When the woman is faced with a man's expectation to have sex with her, and when this woman is also faced with her own sexual desire, she freaks out.

Sex is perceived as traumatic. These women perceive sex to be associated with pain and hurt, kind of punishment.

The following negative thoughts, negative automatic thoughts, prevail in these women's minds.

Sex is dirty. Men are evil, dangerous, one track-minded, they want only sex, and then they will discard you.

Sex inevitably results in pain and hurt. You should feel guilty about cheating. You should feel ashamed for being so whore-ish, etc.

These sentences, negative automatic sentences, play again and again in the woman's mind, as her histrionic side pushes her to engage in sex with strangers and her psychopathic side legitimizes this behavior.

So there's a conflict, an inner conflict, comprised of two or three conflicting and competing voices.

When faced with the prospect of sex, borderline patients panic because of these negative thoughts.

The panic, sometimes, leads to depersonalization. The woman splits from herself. She enters a kind of paralyzing trance. She goes autopilot. She lapses into a dreamlike or nightmare-like state.

If such a woman crosses the line and has full-fledged sex, she experiences dissociation. She forgets certain sexual acts that conflict with her values and boundaries, especially so if she finds them enjoyable.

If you enjoyed this article, you might like the following:

Loving the Borderline in Her Fantasy

Borderline personality disorder is increasingly viewed as a manifestation of complex trauma, often linked to early childhood experiences, including sexual abuse. Individuals with this disorder may engage in compulsive sexual ideation and hypersexuality, often confusing sex with love and pain due to their traumatic backgrounds. Their relationships tend to be characterized by a pattern of selecting unsuitable partners, which allows them to justify their promiscuity and avoid feelings of abandonment. The dynamics between borderlines and narcissists can create a cycle of mutual dysfunction, where their respective pathologies either amplify or cancel each other out, leading to intense but often unhealthy relationships. Ultimately, while loving someone with a personality disorder can be a gamble, it can also foster personal growth if both partners avoid expecting the other to heal their wounds.


Rejection and Abandonment in Cluster B Personality Disorders and Their Intimate

Borderline personality disorder (BPD) has historically been associated with women, largely due to male-centric definitions and societal norms from past decades. Individuals with BPD, along with other Cluster B personality disorders, often struggle with issues of rejection, interpreting both real and perceived rejections as catastrophic, leading to extreme emotional responses and behaviors. The reactions to rejection vary among different personality types, with narcissists exhibiting rage, primary psychopaths viewing it as an obstacle, and secondary psychopaths experiencing profound emotional pain that can lead to aggressive behaviors. Overall, these disorders reflect a complex interplay of arrested development and dysfunctional attachment styles, resulting in significant challenges in interpersonal relationships and emotional regulation.


Borderline Bible: Switching to Identity Disturbance, Psychopathic Self-state (Compilation)

Borderline personality disorder (BPD) is characterized by intense emotional dysregulation, identity disturbance, and a complex interplay of self-states, which can sometimes resemble secondary psychopathy. Individuals with BPD often oscillate between idealizing and devaluing their partners, driven by fears of abandonment and engulfment, leading to chaotic and tumultuous relationships. Their emotional experiences are frequently dissociated, resulting in behaviors that can be impulsive and self-destructive, as they struggle to manage their internal turmoil and maintain a coherent sense of self. Ultimately, the dynamics of BPD highlight a profound need for connection and validation, juxtaposed with an overwhelming fear of intimacy and rejection.


Labile: Borderline Personality Disorder and Narcissism

Borderline personality disorder is a controversial diagnosis that is often found among women. Some scholars believe it is a culture-bound pseudo-syndrome invented by men to serve a patriarchal and misogynistic society. Patients diagnosed with the disorder have chaotic lives and stormy, short-lived, and unstable relationships. Borderlines are impulsive, reckless, and display wildly fluctuating self-worth, self-image, and affect.


Covert Borderline, Classic Borderline - Psychopaths?

Professor Sam Vaknin discusses the proposed new mental health diagnosis of covert borderline, which is more typical of men. He compares and contrasts the covert borderline with the classic or dysregulated borderline. Both types have mood lability and emotional dysregulation, but the classic borderline dissociates from emotions, while the covert borderline rationalizes emotions and becomes a primary psychopath. Many anti-racism activists are covert narcissists and covert borderlines who obtain indirect attention and self-gratification through their activism.


How Narcissist Jekyll Turns into Psychopath Hyde

Collapse in Cluster B personality disorders leads to emotional dysregulation, with individuals experiencing overwhelming states that can manifest as mini collapses, particularly in borderline personality disorder. The etiology of collapse varies among these disorders, often triggered by perceived threats to self-worth or goals, resulting in compensatory reactions that can either be aggressive and narcissistic or avoidant and isolating. The emergence of a psychopathic protector self-state allows individuals to experiment with different identities following a collapse, reflecting a process similar to Erikson's moratorium in adolescence. Ultimately, these personality disorders are fluid and dynamic, with collapse serving as a key mediator in transitions between different self-states and coping mechanisms.


Borderline Lies, Narcissism Myths

Professor Sam Vaknin discusses the misconceptions and myths surrounding lying in individuals with cluster B personality disorders, such as narcissism, borderline, and antisocial personality disorders. He explains that these individuals often confabulate, or create plausible narratives to fill memory gaps, rather than intentionally lying. Vaknin also highlights the different types of lies and their functions, emphasizing the importance of understanding the reasons behind the lies and creating a safe environment for individuals with cluster B disorders to share the truth.


Manipulative Histrionic Craves Attention: HPD Misconceptions Debunked (Literature Review)

Histrionic personality disorder is characterized by exaggerated attention-seeking behaviors and emotionality, often using these traits as tools for manipulation. Recent studies suggest that the disorder is more evenly represented among men and women than previously thought, challenging gender biases in diagnosis. The disorder is linked to various comorbidities, including somatoform disorders and eating disorders, but individuals with histrionic traits are not typically prone to substance abuse, contrary to common stereotypes. Ultimately, histrionic personality disorder appears to be a complex interplay of power dynamics rather than a purely sexual or emotional disorder, with individuals using their behaviors to exert control over their environment and others.


Over-sexed: Histrionic Personality Disorder and Narcissism

Histrionic personality disorder is more commonly diagnosed in women, leading to questions about whether it is a real mental health problem or a reflection of a patriarchal society. Histrionics crave attention and are uncomfortable when not at the center of it, similar to narcissists. They are preoccupied with physical appearance and sexual conquests, and often act flirtatious and seductive. Histrionics are enthusiastic and emotional, but their behavior can be exhausting and off-putting to others.


Histrionic Personality Disorder (HPD): Overview and Issues

Histrionic personality disorder is characterized by a compulsive need for attention, often manifesting through exaggerated emotional displays and provocative behavior, primarily observed in women. The disorder raises questions about its clinical validity versus being a reflection of societal norms, particularly regarding gender roles. Histrionics often misinterpret social cues and relationships, leading to shallow emotional connections and a reliance on sexual manipulation to gain approval and control. The interplay of histrionic traits with other personality disorders, such as borderline and narcissistic disorders, complicates their emotional experiences and relationships, resulting in a cycle of impulsivity, self-sabotage, and a distorted sense of self-worth.

Transcripts Copyright © Sam Vaknin 2010-2024, under license to William DeGraaf
Website Copyright © William DeGraaf 2022-2024
Get it on Google Play
Privacy policy