Background

FIREWALL YOUR Relationships, Yourself: Boundaries vs. Borders

Uploaded 3/13/2023, approx. 7 minute read

What's the difference between borders and boundaries in relationships?

This is today's topic.

My name is Sam Vaknin. I'm a lot lighter. I lost my hair. And I'm the author of Malignant Self-Love, Narcissism Revisited, and a former and current professor of psychology.

So we're going to discuss a bit of a new concept, borders.

You've all heard of boundaries. I'm not quite sure that you know what boundaries are.

People use words without defining them properly and leave a lot of ambiguity and vagueness in their wake.

But today we're going to contemplate both of these concepts.

In relationships, borders are like membranes in the living body. Borders allow in only selective types of communication. Borders require protocols, including communication protocols. Borders rely on rituals and routines. And borders are policed exactly in a national border. Borders are policed by cultural and social mores. Borders therefore are interpersonal. They are dyadic. They are inside the couple.

And again, borders are forms of selectivity. Borders regulate structure, introduce order into relationships. They are like an endoskeleton in a way.

Boundaries are not borders. Boundaries are individual.

You remember that borders are interpersonal.

Two people or more create borders. And borders are usually consensual. They are negotiated. They're compromised. Boundaries are just declared. They're promulgated. They're individual.

Personal boundaries are rules of conduct, red lines in the sand. Any infringement, any breach of the boundary is deemed unacceptable behavior.

You need to set your boundaries clearly, unequivocally, unambiguously, first and foremost to yourself. You need to talk to yourself. You need to ask yourself, how do I protect my dignity, my privacy, my freedom, my priorities, and my rights?

Once you have answered these questions, the list of answers, these are your boundaries.

You then need to communicate your boundaries to people around you, including your intimate partner.

And each boundary has to come with a cost, with a price tag.

So the list of boundaries is a bit like a price list. The cost associated with ignoring or violating the boundary.

This is my boundary.

But if you break it, this is the cost you're going to pay. I don't know. I'm going to leave you. It's a deal break or whatever.

So you need to communicate, not aggressively, not aggressively, but firmly, assertively. You need to communicate your boundaries together with sanctions.

What happens if these boundaries are breached?

And finally, you need to enforce your boundaries. Your credibility depends on a consistent and fair application of these rules of engagement.

Once you have declared the cost of a boundary and the boundary is breached, you need to enforce the cost.

You need to exact the cost. The ability to thrive in intimacy is inextricably linked to the capacity to maintain and enforce personal boundaries and negotiate and compromise interdichoic, intradiadic inside the couple, borders.

So borders and boundaries.

In personality disordered people, both borders and boundaries are sorely missing, lacking, compromised, or they are inconsistent and in constant identity disturbance, for example.

In identity disturbance in borderline personality disorder, the patient has no firm, consistent, long-term, predictable boundaries. Her values, her beliefs, and her boundaries shift all the time. She shapeshifts. She becomes different people. Self-states.

Self-states in healthy people come replete with boundaries.

But in most healthy people, the same boundaries apply to all the self-states.

In mentally ill people, especially people with identity disturbance, for example, borderline, and even to some extent narcissistic, in these patients, in these people, the boundaries, each self-statehas its own list of boundaries. And many of these lists are mutually exclusive.

Intimacy, however fleeting, and of whatever nature, even if it's merely physical intimacy in a one-night stand, intimacy is a tight-rope act.

On the one hand, intimacy involves the disclosure of vulnerabilities and the relaxation of firewalls and protections intended to fend off unwarranted or coerced attention.

On the other hand, real intimacy entails the maintaining of personal autonomy, agency, and self-efficacy.

In other words, real intimacy is at the same time separateness and vulnerability, at the same time keeping boundaries and negotiating borders, at the same time coming close together while not merging, fusing, or succumbing.

So intimacy is a bit paradoxical.

It's a huge problem to negotiate and to reach.

To attain intimacy, one needs to feel sufficiently secure of one's core identity, self-worth, self-esteem, internal regulation, and boundaries.

So secure that you feel safe to invite another person in.

Intimacy is an invitation extended to another person.

And exactly like in a real home or a boat, you won't invite a stranger in unless you feel totally safe.

The mentally ill tend to enmesh, engulf, merge, or fuse with other people. And then they push them away and flee.

And this is known as approachavoidancerepetitioncompulsion.

It's impossible to negotiate borders or to maintain boundaries in such a pendulum. It's very difficult.

The dysfunctional attachment styles are the outcomes of twin contradictory anxieties, the separation insecurity, abandonment anxiety on the one hand, and government anxiety on the other hand.

Wherever anxiety prevails, there is a pervasive lack of safety, a sense of insecurity, dread, fear even.

In these situations, it's not possible to have intimacy. It's very unlikely to negotiate a consensual set of borders.

And above all, your boundaries are in flux. Sometimes they're rigid and exaggerated, paranoid and aggressive. And sometimes they're mushy and fuzzy and permeable and to all intents and purposesnon-existent.

[ Pause ].

If you enjoyed this article, you might like the following:

Is Fantasy Good for You? Fantasy vs. Lies vs. Delusion vs. Confabulation

Fantasy is a psychological defense mechanism that helps people cope with an unbearable reality. There are two types of fantasy: person-centered and process-centered. Person-centered fantasies revolve around another person and often dissolve into reality, leading to chaos. Process-centered fantasies are based on a narrative or impersonal process and can be more benign and long-lasting. Transitioning from person-centered to process-centered fantasies can be a therapeutic goal for individuals struggling with mental health issues.


3 Phases of Borderline’s Rollercoaster

Professor Sam Vaknin discusses the regulatory cycle of the borderline personality disorder. The borderline seeks an intimate partner to provide her with a sense of inner peace, stability, and safety. The intimate partner becomes an extension of the borderline's inner turmoil, and the borderline creates a shared fantasy with the partner. The cycle has three phases: shared fantasy, disillusionment, and transactional regulatory valley. The cycle is inevitable and ineluctable, and the borderline will try to recreate a shared fantasy with the partner or an ex-partner or become sexually self-trashing.


No Intimacy Without Personal Boundaries (Q&A)

Intimacy skills are inextricably linked to the capacity to maintain and enforce personal boundaries. People with personality disorders don't have personal boundaries, which makes it impossible for them to do intimacy. Intimacy is a balancing act between separateness and togetherness, sharing commonalities and having a private life separate from the partner. The younger generations have tremendous deficiencies in relationship and intimacy skills because they don't have the chance to experience even intimacy in relationships.


Borderline Personality Disorder Patient Therapy Notes

Do is a 26-year-old female diagnosed with borderline personality disorder. She struggles with maintaining a stable sense of self-worth and self-esteem, and her confidence in holding onto men is low. She has had six serious relationships in the past year, all of which ended due to violent fights over trivial matters. Do admits to physically assaulting three of her ex-partners and has suicidal ideation, which sometimes manifests in minor acts of self-injury and self-mutilation. She also struggles with drug use, shopping addiction, and binge eating.


Intimacy and Jealousy Regulate Relationships

In relationships, there are two ways to regulate behavior: intimacy and romantic jealousy. Healthy relationships achieve a balance between the two, but those with mood disorders or personality disorders cannot achieve intimacy and instead become fused together. To prevent abandonment, the partner may provoke romantic jealousy, but this can lead to the exact opposite effect and drive the other partner away. Finding the balance between intimacy and jealousy is difficult, and exaggerated regulatory behaviors can kill the relationship. The modern condition is that many people give up on relationships altogether.


Is Your Pet Cat a Psychopath? (PURR, GASP!)

A recent study by researchers at the University of Liverpool has found that all cats have some level of psychopathy, with the reason being that in an ancestral environment that demanded self-sufficiency, wild cats that had higher levels of psychopathic traits may have been more successful in acquiring resources such as food, territory and mating opportunities. The study settled on the conclusion that all cats are psychopathic to some degree. The questions asked in the study are pretty generic, such as my cat demands attention, or my cat disobeys rules, or behaviors that are pretty standard for the species.


How Borderlines Abuse Themselves ( DBT)

The lecture discusses the victimization of borderline patients, focusing on their self-destructive behaviors and internal struggles. It delves into the concepts of inhibited grieving, unrelenting crisis, active passivity, apparent competence, emotional vulnerability, and self-invalidation in the context of borderline personality disorder. The speaker emphasizes the intense emotional experiences and the difficulty in regulating emotions that borderlines face, leading to self-criticism and self-victimization. The lecture also touches on the potential transition from the self-state of a borderline to that of a psychopath.


Hijacked by Fantasies in Cluster B (Intl. Conference on Psychiatry and Mental Health, May 2021)

Fantasy is a powerful psychological defense mechanism that can lead to mental health issues when it becomes malignant and all-pervasive. In small doses, fantasies can be healthy and help individuals cope with frustrating or intimidating environments. However, when fantasies become entrenched and hijack an individual's emotions, cognitions, memories, and identity, they can impair reality testing and lead to dysfunction. In extreme cases, individuals with Cluster B personality disorders, such as narcissistic and borderline personality disorders, may experience a confusion between internal and external objects, leading to a state that is close to psychosis.


Borderline Bible: Switching to Identity Disturbance, Psychopathic Self-state (Compilation)

Professor Sam Vaknin discusses the perspective of a person with borderline personality disorder (BPD) towards their intimate partner. He describes two phases in the relationship: the approach phase and the avoidance phase. In the approach phase, the person with BPD sees their partner as their world, savior, and stabilizer of moods. They feel completed and whole with their partner. In the avoidance phase, the person with BPD feels overwhelmed by pain, anticipates abandonment, and may engage in acting out behaviors like cheating or other reckless actions. They may experience dissociation and view their partner as wanting to control or harm them. The cycle of approach and avoidance is compulsive and not mitigated by external factors. Vaknin emphasizes the intense and chaotic nature of relationships with individuals with BPD.


Borderline's Miracle Healing

Borderline personality disorder (BPD) is a mental health issue that affects 1-2% of the general population. Contrary to popular belief, BPD is not untreatable and has a positive prognosis over time. Studies have shown that most patients with BPD improve with time, and by age 45, a significant portion of patients will have healed spontaneously. However, while the disorder may remit, some dysfunctional behaviors persist, and there is a need for a two-step treatment approach: first, tackle the core disorder, and then focus on teaching the recovered patient functional skills.

Transcripts Copyright © Sam Vaknin 2010-2024, under license to William DeGraaf
Website Copyright © William DeGraaf 2022-2024
Get it on Google Play
Privacy policy