Background

Narcissism of Small Differences

Uploaded 2/23/2011, approx. 5 minute read

My name is Sam Vaknin. I am the author of Malignant Self-Love, Narcissism Revisited.

It is a common belief that the more marked and pronounced the differences between newcomers and citizens, the stronger the resultant racism and xenophobia. After all, white Frenchmen, American and Dutch hotheads, attack black folks, white versus black, the ultimate difference.

The self-proclaimed liberal white often harbor averse racism, unconscious racist attitudes. But this is only half the truth. The ugliest manifestations of racism up to genocide are reserved to immigrants who look, act and talk like us. The more they try to emulate and imitate us, the harder they attempt to belong, the more ferocious our rejection of them.

Sigmund Freud coined the phrase, Narcissism of Small Differences, in a paper titled, The Taboo of Virginity that he published in 1917. Referring to earlier work by British anthropologist, Ernst Erpmann, Freud said that we reserve our most virulent emotions, aggression, hatred, envy, towards those who resemble us the most. We feel threatened not by the other with whom we have little in common, but by the nearly we who mirror and reflect us. The nearly we imperil our selfhood and challenge our uniqueness, perfection and superiority.

And these are of course the fundamentals of the narcissist sense of self-worth.

So someone who is very much like the narcissist provokes in him primitive narcissistic defenses and leads him to adopt desperate measures to protect, preserve and restore the appropriate balance where the narcissist has the upper hand and the newcomer is an inferior life form. I call it the Galiver Array of Defense Mechanisms.

The very existence of the nearly he constitutes a narcissistic injury. The narcissist feels humiliated, shamed and embarrassed not to be special. And he reacts with envy and aggression towards this source of frustration.

The more reminiscent the newcomer is of the narcissist, the more aggressively the narcissist reacts. In doing so, the narcissist resorts to splitting, projection and projective identification. All of these are primitive psychological defense mechanisms typical of infants.

The narcissist attributes to other people personal traits that he dislikes in himself and he forces them to behave in conformity with his expectations. In other words, the narcissist sees in others those parts of himself that he cannot accountenance and cannot deny. He forces people around him to become him and to reflect his shameful behaviors, hidden fears, frailties and forbidden wishes.

But how does a narcissist avoid the realization that what he loudly decries and derides is actually a part of himself?

Well, he avoids this painful truth by exaggerating or even dreaming up and creatively inventing differences between his qualities in conduct and other people's. The more hostile he becomes towards the nearly him, the easier it is to distinguish himself from the other.

To maintain this self-differentiating aggression, the narcissist stokes the fires of hostility by obsessively and vengefully nurturing grudges and hurts, many of them imagined. It dwells on injustice and pain inflicted on him by these stereotypically bad or unworthy people. He devalues and dehumanizes them and plots revenge to achieve closure.

In the process, he indulges in grandiose fantasies aimed to boost his feelings of inflated omnipotence and magical immunity. In the process of acquiring an adversary, the narcissist blocks out information that threatens to undermine his emerging self-perception as righteous and the offended party.

He begins to base his own identity on the brewing conflict that is by now a major preoccupation and a defining or even all pervasive dimension of his existence.

Consider, for instance, the conflict between Nazis or Germans and Jews. This became the defining dimension and axis and pivot of the Third Reich.

Very much the same dynamic applies to coping with major differences between the narcissist and others. He emphasizes the large disparities while transforming even the most minor ones into decisive and unbridgeable.

Deep inside, the narcissist is continuously subject to a knowing suspicion that his self-perception as omnipotent, omniscient and irresistible is indeed dubious or flawed. He knows that it is confabulated and unrealistic. When criticized, the narcissist actually agrees with the critique. That's the source of his rage.

In other words, there are only minor differences between the narcissist and his detractors. They are in consensus with regards to the narcissist and his deficiencies.

But this consensus threatens the narcissist's internal cohesion. Hence, the wild wrath and rage at any hint of disagreement, resistance or debate, precisely because the narcissist agrees with his detractors that he attacks them so viciously.

Similarly, intimacy brings people close together, makes them more similar. There are only minor differences between intimate partners.

The narcissist perceives this as a threat to his sense of uniqueness. He reacts to intimacy or to attempts at intimacy or to intimations of intimacy by devaluing the source of his fears. His maid, his spouse, his lover, his partner, or in society, the immigrant who tries very hard to belong. The narcissist reestablishes the boundaries and the distinctions that were removed by intimacy.

As restored, he is emotionally ready to embark on another round of idealization, and this is called the Approach Avoidance Repetition Complex.

In a study titled War and Relativeness published by the National Bureau of Economic Research, the authors, Enrico Sponza Orwe, Romain Vaccia, concluded, the degree of genealogical relatedness between populations has a positive effect on their conflict propensities. In other words, the more related two populations are, the more they are in conflict. Because more closely related populations, on average, tend to interact more and develop more disputes over a set of common issues, populations that are genetically closer are more prone to go to war with each other, even after controlling for a wide set of measures of geographic distance and other factors that affect conflict, including measures of trade and democracy. The more similar you are to someone, the more you want to distance yourself, the more you want to render yourself unique, the more aggressive and violent and vicious you are likely to be towards him or her.

If you enjoyed this article, you might like the following:

Nationalism vs. Patriotism: Narcissism vs. Self-love

Patriotism is characterized by a healthy self-love that embraces pride in one's identity and culture, while nationalism emerges from feelings of shame and exclusion, often leading to aggressive devaluation of others. The concept of "narcissism of small differences" explains that individuals often harbor the most intense hostility towards those who are similar to them, as they feel threatened by their reflections. Narcissists react defensively to perceived similarities, employing mechanisms like projection and devaluation to maintain their sense of superiority and uniqueness. Ultimately, conflicts often arise from internal struggles, revealing that the true adversary lies within oneself.


Who is the Antinarcissist? A Nothingness Narcissist! (Pasche, Bollas, Green)

Anti-narcissism, as proposed by Francis Pasche, refers to a psychological dynamic where energy is directed outward, focusing on others rather than the self, contrasting with narcissism, which is inwardly directed. This outward investment can manifest as altruism or charity, but paradoxically, it may also lead to self-neglect and a diminishment of the self, aligning it with the concept of thanatos, or the death drive. The anti-narcissist often exhibits masochistic tendencies, deriving a sense of grandiosity from their failures and self-destructive behaviors, which serve to attract attention and maintain a sense of control over their circumstances. Ultimately, this dynamic reflects a complex interplay between self-denial and the pursuit of external validation, complicating the traditional understanding of narcissism and its manifestations.


Four Pillars of Self-love

Self-love involves having a realistic and healthy view of oneself, contrasting with the grandiosity of narcissism or the self-deprecation of others. It requires three tests: a realistic self-assessment, the pursuit of happiness, and the pursuit of favorable outcomes. Four conditions must be met for healthy self-love: self-awareness, self-acceptance, self-trust, and self-efficacy, each building upon the previous one. Ultimately, self-love is essential for survival and well-being, guiding individuals toward happiness and effective decision-making.


Masochistic Covert Antinarcissist

Anti-narcissism is a form of narcissism characterized by the externalization of emotional and cognitive resources, leading individuals to appear altruistic while actually seeking self-degradation and failure. This concept, introduced by Francis Pash, suggests that anti-narcissists invest in self-trashing behaviors, often linked to masochism, as a means of achieving a sense of calm and merging with their empty core. Unlike typical narcissists who seek grandiosity, anti-narcissists derive a sense of identity from their defeats and failures, often rejecting intimacy and success in favor of self-destructive patterns. The interplay between masochism and narcissism reveals a complex dynamic where self-inflicted suffering serves as a strategy for obtaining narcissistic supply, ultimately reinforcing their sense of worthlessness while paradoxically providing a form of self-affirmation.


Narcissist As Employee

Narcissistic employees pose significant challenges in hierarchical workplaces due to their aversion to authority and teamwork, which they perceive as threats to their inflated self-image. They often engage in destructive behaviors such as bullying, conspiracy, and subversion to restore their sense of superiority and retaliate against perceived injuries. Their presence can corrupt corporate culture, leading to widespread dysfunction and unethical practices, as they manipulate others into conforming to their delusional narratives. The most effective strategy for organizations is to identify and remove narcissistic individuals promptly to prevent the spread of their toxic influence.


I Can Achieve and Do Anything If I Only Put My Mind to It

The belief that there are no unrealistic aspirations and that positive outcomes are guaranteed is narcissistic and delusional. To avoid self-deception, we need to accept our limitations, learn from our mistakes, and develop a growth mindset that embraces challenges and sees failure as an opportunity for growth. To develop a realistic self-assessment, make a list of your positive and negative traits and ask others to do the same. Compare the lists and grade the answers on a scale of one to five.


Whistleblower: Glorified Snitch/Grass or Moral Crusader?

Whistleblowers often lead double lives, balancing loyalty to their organizations and personal relationships with a commitment to expose wrongdoing, which can reveal a duality akin to that of spies. Research indicates that a staggering 97% of whistleblower complaints are unsubstantiated, with many motivated by revenge, envy, or a desire for attention rather than genuine moral concerns. The act of whistleblowing can become a defining identity for individuals, often reflecting traits associated with narcissism and psychopathy, as they seek recognition and validation for their actions. While a small percentage of whistleblowers may act selflessly, the overwhelming majority exhibit characteristics that suggest a deeper psychological pathology, complicating the narrative of whistleblowing as a purely noble endeavor.


Why Narcissist Rewrites History (Recency Bias)

Grandiosity in narcissism is a cognitive distortion that allows individuals to perceive themselves as superior and perfect, often as a defense against their fragile self-esteem. This distortion manifests through various biases, such as recency bias, where narcissists view their past negatively to support their victimhood narrative, and anchoring bias, where they selectively compare themselves to inferior benchmarks to maintain their inflated self-image. Additionally, narcissists experience a recency illusion, believing their thoughts and ideas are groundbreaking, despite often being recycled from others. Ultimately, these cognitive biases create a distorted perception of reality, leading to a convoluted relationship with truth and time, where the narcissist's self-narrative is a fictional construct rather than an accurate reflection of their experiences.


Raging Narcissist: Merely Pissed-off?

Narcissistic rage is a phenomenon that occurs when a narcissist is frustrated in their pursuit of narcissistic supply, causing narcissistic injury. The narcissist then projects a bad object onto the source of their frustration and rages against a perceived evil entity that has injured and frustrated them. Narcissistic rage is not the same as normal anger and has two forms: explosive and pernicious or passive-aggressive. People with personality disorders are in a constant state of anger, which is effectively suppressed most of the time, and they are afraid to show that they are angry to meaningful others because they are afraid to lose them.


Self-destructive Narcissist = Masochist? (Compilation)

Anti-narcissism is a complex psychological construct that diverges from traditional notions of altruism and selflessness, instead representing a form of narcissism that externalizes emotional investment. This concept, introduced by Francis Pash, suggests that anti-narcissists project their emotional resources outward, often appearing benevolent while actually seeking self-supply through self-degradation and masochism. The anti-narcissistic individual may engage in behaviors that seem altruistic but are rooted in a desire for self-punishment and humiliation, reflecting a deep-seated internal conflict and a need for validation through suffering. This behavior can manifest in various ways, including sexual self-trashing, where individuals engage in reckless sexual encounters as a means of coping with their emotional turmoil and reinforcing their negative self-image. Ultimately, the anti-narcissist's actions are driven by a complex interplay of self-loathing, a desire for connection, and a paradoxical need for self-destruction.

Transcripts Copyright © Sam Vaknin 2010-2024, under license to William DeGraaf
Website Copyright © William DeGraaf 2022-2024
Get it on Google Play
Privacy policy