Pathologizing Rebellious Youth: Oppositional Defiant Disorder (ODD)

Uploaded 11/29/2010, approx. 3 minute read

I am Sam Vaknin, and I am the author of Malignant Self-Love, Narcissism Revisited.

If you are a rebellious youth, a teenager, and you have not been diagnosed with conduct disorder, you are still at risk of being labelled and pathologized by the mental health profession.

The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual informs us that the essential feature of oppositional Defiant Disorder is a recurrent pattern of negativistic, defiant, disobedient and hostile behavior towards authority figures, pattern that persists for six months.

This is an unbelievable text. It is Orwellian, the big brother, and it gets worse.

If you are under 18 years old and you lose your temper, you argue with adults, or you actively, as the DSM puts it, defy or refuse to comply with the requests or rules of adults.

You deliberately do things to annoy, said adults. You blame others for your mistakes or misbehavior.

Well, if you do these things, you are unquestionably a sick little puppy. And who is to make these value judgments?

Well, adults. Adult psychiatrists, psychologists, social workers and therapists. All of them, mind you, authority figures.

What if you disagree with these authority figures? Well, they get annoyed. And the very fact that they get annoyed is proof positive that you are afflicted with oppositional Defiant Disorder.

Well, did anyone mention catch-22? And the charade continues, masquerading as science.

If you are touchy, if you get easily annoyed, for instance, by the half-baked diagnosis rendered by certain mental health practitioners, you are definitely afflicted with oppositional Defiant Disorder. You're allowed to be touchy when you're an adult. It's called assertiveness. You are allowed to get pissed off when you're above the crucial, though utterly arbitrary, age limit. Then it is called expressing your emotions, which is by and large a good thing and encouraged.

So the charlatans tell us that psychology is an exact science, not merely an elaborate literary exercise. The diagnosis of oppositional Defiant Disorder seems to put the whole mental health profession to shame.

The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, this manual of the Potemkin science known as clinical psychology, continues to enlighten us.

If you are habitually angry and resentful, spiteful or vindictive, and these traits impair your normal social, academic or occupational functioning, whatever normal means in today's pluralistic and atomic culture.

Well, if you are, beware, you may be harboring oppositional Defiant Disorder.

It is not clear what the DSM means by occupational when oppositional Defiant Disorder typically applies to primary school-aged children. Perhaps we will find out in the next iteration of the DSM, DSM 5.

The DSM continues, the behaviors attributed to oppositional Defiant Disorder must occur more frequently than is typically observed in individuals of comparable age and developmental level.

That is not very helpful. If the child is psychotic or suffers from a mood disorder, oppositional Defiant Disorder should not be diagnosed and elaborates the DSM.

Why am I bothering you with this tripe? Because the DSM is ominously clear. The diagnosis is not made if criteria are met for conduct disorder or antisocial personality disorder in an individual above the age of 18.

Well, get this straight. If you are above the age of 18 and you are stubborn, resistant to directions, unwilling to compromise, give in or negotiate with adults and peers, as the DSM puts it, ignore others, argue if you fail to accept blame for misdeeds and deliberately annoy others, annoy.

Do you stand a good chance of being diagnosed as a psychopath? Let us hope that the scholars of the Diagnostic and Statistical 5 committee have the good sense to remove this latent tool of social control from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual itself.

But don't count on it and don't argue with them if they don't. They may diagnose you with something.

If you enjoyed this article, you might like the following:

Body Language of the Personality Disordered

Patients with personality disorders have a body language specific to their personality disorder. The body language comprises an unequivocal series of subtle and not-so-subtle presenting signs. A patient's body language usually reflects the underlying mental health problem or pathology. In itself, body language cannot and should not be used as a diagnostic tool.

Children Psychopaths? Conduct Disorder

Children and adolescents with conduct disorder are budding psychopaths who repeatedly and deliberately violate the rights of others and breach age-appropriate social norms and rules. They are socially, occupationally, and academically dysfunctional, and their diagnosis changes to antisocial personality disorder or psychopathy beyond the age of 18. These children are in denial and tend to minimize their problems and blame others for their misbehavior and failures. Adolescents with conduct disorder are often embroiled in fights, both verbal and physical, and many underage muggers, extortionists, hearse snatchers, rapists, robbers, shoplifters, burglars, arsonists, vandals, and animal torturers are diagnosed with conduct disorder.

Borderline Woman as Dissociative Secondary Psychopath

Borderline Personality Disorder and Psychopathy may not be as different as previously thought. Recent studies suggest that Borderline and Histrionic Personality Disorders may be manifestations of secondary type psychopathy in women. Survivors of Complex Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (CPTSD) also exhibit psychopathic and narcissistic behaviors. Borderline Personality Disorder can be described as a subspecies of Dissociative Identity Disorder, with mood lability and emotional dysregulation being outward manifestations of changes in self-states.

Morally Insane Psychopath: A Brief History of Psychopaths and Antisocials

The concept of personality disorders began less than a hundred years ago, with the French psychiatrist Pinel coining the phrase "mal de son" to describe patients who lacked impulse control and were prone to outbursts of violence. The term "moral insanity" was widely used for almost a century, but physicians sought to replace it with something more objective and scientific. The diagnosis of psychopathy has been expanded to include people who harm and inconvenience themselves, as well as others. Today, most practitioners rely on either the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual or the International Classification of Diseases to diagnose personality disorders.

Latest On Psychopathy, Antisocial Personality Disorder

Antisocial personality disorder is the official diagnosis, with no mention of psychopathy in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual. The extreme end of antisocial personality disorder is considered psychopathy by some, but not all. The disorder is difficult to reverse and is linked to aggression, violence, and substance abuse. There are no current diagnostic standards, and treatment options are limited. The disorder is associated with a lack of remorse and disregard for the rights of others.

Pedophile Narcissist: Narcissism, Pedophilia, and Hebephilia

Pedophiles are attracted to pre-pubescent children and come from all walks of life. They have no common socioeconomic background, and most have not been sexually abused in childhood. Pedophiles are drawn to what children symbolize, such as innocence and trust, and they view their relationships with children in a peculiar light. Pedophilia is a culture-bound syndrome, and the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual is considering rendering hebephilia as a subtype of pedophilia.

Autism, ADHD, BPD, or Narcissism? (Compilation)

The text discusses the challenges in diagnosing and differentiating between psychopathy, autism, schizoid personality disorder, and PTSD or CPTSD. These conditions often present similarly, with reduced affect display, reticent self-disclosure, defensive and aggressive body language, and idiosyncratic use of language. Clinicians must look for specific signs, such as attitudes towards sex and intimacy, deceitfulness, goal orientation, and hypervigilance, to accurately diagnose and treat these distinct disorders. The etiologies of these disorders are different, with psychopathy possibly rooted in brain damage affecting empathy and emotions, autism characterized by obliviousness to social cues and concrete thinking, schizoid personality disorder marked by a desire for solitude, and trauma survivors repressing emotions due to the overwhelming nature of their experiences.

Controversial P Factor Unifying Mental Illness

The P factor is a controversial concept in psychology that suggests a common denominator to all mental disorders. It challenges the traditional approach of diagnosing people based on lists of symptoms or behaviors. The debate surrounding the P factor raises questions about the usefulness of labels and the need for customized treatments. Early intervention is key to preventing severe mental illness later in life.

New Year on Planet Mental Illness

Mental illness is a state of disconnect, a state of discontinuity and disjointedness. There's no gyroscope, no core identity, no guiding light, no northern star, no caressing hand, no embrace and no hugs and no warmth and no acceptance and no love. Mental illness is a cancer of the soul. It's all-consuming. It's all devouring. It's merciless. And its advance is unhindered by any external intervention.

How One Becomes a Psychopath: Antisocial Personality Disorder Revisited

Professor Sam Vaknin discusses the diagnosis of Antisocial Personality Disorder (ASPD) and its relationship to psychopathy, noting that it is difficult to treat as it is a childhood disorder that starts around ages six to eight and is associated with other comorbidities. He suggests that ASPD, along with borderline personality disorder and narcissism, are childhood disorders that should be treated with child psychology. Vaknin also discusses the history of the diagnosis of ASPD, noting that childhood behavior problems are the best predictors of adult antisocial behavior. He suggests that ASPD is a societal disorder and that we need to focus on troubled children who are at the greatest risk of developing ASPD.

Transcripts Copyright © Sam Vaknin 2010-2024, under license to William DeGraaf
Website Copyright © William DeGraaf 2022-2024
Get it on Google Play
Privacy policy