Background

Staring Into Abyss: Failed Healer's Confession

Uploaded 4/5/2021, approx. 5 minute read

I have been trying to help people in psychology ever since 1995, and I want to share with you an experience that is common to many mental health professionals and practitioners, psychologists, those who teach psychology like me and others.

When we work with clients, when we work with patients, sometimes I feel so helpless. When I work with a client whose mental health condition is hopeless, is unmanageable, I feel hopeless and sometimes unmanageable.

It's like these nightmares or horror movies where a small child is trapped under a transparent sheet of ice in a lake, running out of oxygen, drowning in the cold dark water, and you're trying desperately to break the ice, you're trying to reach in, drag him out, resuscitate him with your breath of life, provide him with warmth, and you just can't, you just can't because the ice won't break, won't give way.

And he's, the child is flailing and screaming and bubbles come all over and you try so hard and you keep failing and failing and failing until the child dies right in front of you.

Sometimes the experience of treating people, counseling people, trying to help them with their life crisis, traits, dysfunctional behaviors, wrong choices and decisions, sometimes the experience is exactly like this nightmare.

Self-interested hype by therapists aside, many patients, many clients are just beyond help. They have strayed far away, too far from home, their minds are jumbled, tangled messes, a chaos pulsating with the trauma and agonies that had shaped them.

And so you're trespassing. There's no access there. It's a primordial, primordial jungle teeming with predators, dark fears, creatures glined out of convoluted, perverted fairy tales. It's an enchanted place and you're drawn as a therapist, you're drawn inexorably deeper and deeper into this forest, knowing that it could spell your own doom.

Because I have breaking news for you. Therapists, psychologists, counselors, coaches, they're all human. They're all exactly like you. They all have their own mental health issues. They can all be triggered. They can all disintegrate.

When the therapist comes across this kind of patient, the heart of darkness, the deep space, the void, the howling winds amidst an emptiness, the hollow of mirrors with nothing reflected in them.

When a therapist comes across a patient like this, he's liable to lose his mind. It's frightening. It's a terrifying experience and yet in some inexplicable way, it's compelling. It's addictive.

It's as though the patient's mind or the patient somehow pushes all the buttons, somehow activates all the triggers, somehow merges malevolently but inadvertently with the therapist.

It's like an emanation, an apparition, an entity of sorts.

So therapists are traumatized. There's even a diagnosis for traumatized therapies, vicarious trauma. They burn out like candles. They melt down. They act out. They decompensate. They dysregulate. Therapists react sometimes very badly.

And above all is this knowing, harrowing feeling of impotence, of rage, rage at whatever had gripped the patient.

This rescuer and saviour complex, the need to rescue the patient, to save her, to resurrect her, to revive her, to resuscitate her, it's like mouth to mouth.

You are the defibrillator. Her heart is in your hands. You need to squeeze it, to massage it, make her come alive.

But she's dead inside and has been dead inside a long time.

It is this encounter with death, this terrifying interaction with a zombie that drives some of us sometimes to the brink.

Some of these patients inherited miswired brains or toxic cocktails of neurotransmitters and hormones. Sometimes it's just biology. Sometimes their brains are wrongly put together. The neuroplasticity worked against them. They are hardwired for trauma and despair and dissociation and denial and fear and anxiety and depression.

And sometimes you can see in their eyes a flicker of a human being incarcerated, imprisoned in this cell whose walls are ever closing in.

Anyone to reach out and extract them, extricate them. I lose sleep over such clients. I agonize, I fret, I pit the full might of my formidable intellect only to be defeated time and again.

And it is a humbling, traumatizing experience, especially for a grandiose narcissist, which I am.

I don't know. Maybe I just see myself in them and I lash out at my own reflection.

It's mini-motification every single time.

These clients are so vulnerable, so raw, so abused, exploited and shunned by everyone.

And they succeed to penetrate all my defenses and they dysregulate me badly.

Many of these clients are endowed. Many of them are great looking and sexy and sensitive and even hyper intelligent and all of them are such god-awful waste, such unmitigated, unadulterated desert.

And this cruel discrepancy between what could have been and what is induces burnout in those of us who attempt to salve and heal and soothe and hold.


When I studied medicine in my youth, I had witnessed the most authoritarian, intimidating and resilient doctors, medical doctors, heads of departments, gods in their own mini kingdoms.

I had witnessed them dissolve into tears, having lost a patient that they got attached to despite all the training, despite all the warnings to not get attached to patients.

But they did and they cried like babies.

And sometimes, sometimes having confronted some of these patients in secret, when no one is watching, so do I.

If you enjoyed this article, you might like the following:

When Your Pain Traumatizes Others: Vicarious (Secondary) Trauma

Vicarious trauma is a significant psychological phenomenon affecting mental health practitioners who work with traumatized clients, leading to symptoms similar to those of post-traumatic stress disorder. It arises from the emotional residue of exposure to others' trauma, causing therapists to experience distress, flashbacks, and a breakdown in their worldview. Unlike burnout, which can be alleviated through changes in work conditions, vicarious trauma requires professional help to address and heal. The increasing prevalence of trauma in society amplifies the risk of vicarious trauma, making it essential for practitioners to develop coping strategies and seek support when needed.


Dead Parents Clone Narcissists (and Codependents And Borderlines)

There are three types of trauma: self-inflicted, reality-inflicted, and parental-inflicted, with parental trauma being particularly detrimental to personal development. Reality-inflicted traumas can lead to growth by challenging one's beliefs and self-image, while self-inflicted traumas often arise from introspection and can also promote personal growth. In contrast, parental trauma, especially from a "dead mother," can result in dysfunction and hinder emotional regulation, leading to various psychological issues. The development of a healthy self involves recognizing boundaries and creating a narrative that distinguishes between internal and external objects, ultimately fostering empathy and a sense of safety in the world.


Are You Paranoid or Just Hypervigilant?

Hyper-vigilance, paranoid ideation, and conspiracism are distinct psychological phenomena, each with unique characteristics. Hyper-vigilance is a post-traumatic response marked by heightened alertness to potential threats, while paranoid ideation involves persistent, unfounded beliefs of persecution and is often a product of impaired reality testing. Conspiracism, on the other hand, is the tendency to interpret facts in a way that creates plausible but incorrect narratives, often involving creativity and imagination. Trauma can trigger these responses, and maintaining mental health involves recognizing the likelihood of scenarios and ruling out the implausible, focusing on what is likely rather than merely possible.


How Sick Parents Destroy You (or Why I Am Childless)

Parents play a crucial role in shaping their children's mental health and overall well-being, with their behavior significantly influencing the child's development. While genetics can predispose individuals to certain mental health disorders, it is the environment created by parents that activates these predispositions. Dysfunctional parenting, characterized by neglect, abuse, or unrealistic expectations, can lead to severe psychological issues in children, including boundary violations and identity confusion. Ultimately, the intergenerational transmission of trauma and mental illness underscores the profound impact of parental mental health on the next generation.


Abuse Victim's Body: Effects of Abuse and Its Aftermath

Abuse and torture have long-lasting and frequently irreversible effects on the victim's body, including panic attacks, hypervigilance, sleep disturbances, flashbacks, intrusive memories, and suicidal ideation. Victims experience psychosomatic or real bodily symptoms, some of them induced by the secretion of stress hormones, such as cortisol. Victims are affected by abuse in a variety of ways, including PTSD, which can develop in the wake of verbal and emotional abuse, in the aftermath of drawn-out traumatic situations such as domestic divorce.


Psychology of Torture Victim

Torture causes victims to lose their mental resilience and sense of freedom, leading to alienation and an inability to communicate or empathize with others. The victim may identify with the torturer, leading to traumatic bonding and a craving for pain. Torture is an act of deep, traumatic indoctrination that can lead to post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, anxiety, and other psychological sequelae. Victims often feel helpless and powerless, and bystanders may feel guilty and ashamed for not preventing the atrocity. The victim's attempts to repress memories can result in psychosomatic illnesses.


Psychology of Political Assassinations, Aftermath: Messianic Saviors (TalkTV with Trisha Goddard)

Political assassins often exhibit traits of isolation and dichotomous thinking, viewing the world in terms of good versus evil, which is rooted in narcissism. Their motivations are highly personalized, leading them to mythologize both themselves and their targets, believing they are on a mission to cleanse the world. The aftermath of an assassination attempt can significantly shape public perception, with survivors often portrayed as victims or martyrs, while successful assassinations can lead to the target being canonized in public memory. Political violence stifles honest discourse and can inadvertently benefit those who are willing to disregard ethical constraints, potentially giving an advantage to more extreme factions.


Overprotective Parents And Manipulative Helplessness

Overprotective parents create a traumatic environment for their children by denying them access to reality and preventing them from experiencing necessary challenges and losses that foster personal growth. This overprotectiveness stems from the parents' own anxieties and insecurities, leading to a stunted development in the child, who becomes dependent and struggles with social interactions and boundaries. As adults, these children often exhibit learned helplessness and may manipulate others through feigned dependency, perpetuating a cycle of dysfunction in their relationships. Ultimately, this dynamic results in a failure to individuate and a distorted internal working model, leaving the child unable to navigate the complexities of the world independently.


Post-traumatic Growth (PTG) or Positive Disintegration?

Psychology is often criticized for lacking rigor and scientific methodology, contributing to the replication crisis where many studies cannot be replicated. Trauma is defined as a profound conflict between reality and personal beliefs or models, leading to a breakdown of understanding and identity, while post-traumatic growth is deemed an oxymoron because trauma does not foster growth but rather regression and dysfunction. The confusion between trauma and life crises is highlighted, as the latter can lead to positive adaptations and personal development, whereas trauma is characterized by its unexpected and surreal nature, hindering growth. The concept of positive disintegration, proposed by Kazimierz Dabrowski, suggests that stress and anxiety can lead to personal growth, but this process is distinct from trauma, which ultimately stunts development and creates maladaptive changes.


How Trauma Breaks You Apart (Structural Dissociation in Cold Therapy)

Dissociation can be understood as either a malfunction in integrating traumatic experiences or as a primitive defense mechanism in response to extreme trauma, particularly in children. The theory of structural dissociation posits that dissociation results from an integrative deficit, leading to the formation of distinct self-states, namely the apparently normal part (ANP) and the emotional part (EP), which interact in a conflictual manner. Trauma significantly impairs the ability to integrate experiences, resulting in symptoms that manifest as either psychoform or somatoform issues, and can lead to personality disorders being reconceptualized as disorders of integration rather than distinct personality conditions. The lecture emphasizes the importance of understanding the role of trauma in shaping these dissociative states and the need for therapeutic approaches that address the underlying trauma rather than merely the dissociative symptoms.

Transcripts Copyright © Sam Vaknin 2010-2024, under license to William DeGraaf
Website Copyright © William DeGraaf 2022-2024
Get it on Google Play
Privacy policy